1940: No. 7 C/LB Clyde "Bulldog" Turner (HOF)

1944: No. 5 HB Steve Van Buren (HOF)

1945: No. 5 HB/E Elroy Hirsch (HOF)

1946: No. 5 T George Connor (HOF)

1957: No. 5 QB Len Dawson (HOF)

1958: No. 7 LB Chuck Howley

1961: No. 5 TE Mike Ditka (HOF)

1964: No. 5 DE Carl Eller (HOF)

1965: No. 5 RB Gale Sayers (HOF)

1976: No. 5 DB Mike Haynes (HOF)

1979: No. 7 QB Phil Simms

1988: No. 7 WR Sterling Sharpe

1989: No. 5 DB Deion Sanders (HOF)

1990: No. 5 LB Junior Seau (HOF)

1992: No. 7 DB Troy Vincent

1994: No. 7 DT Bryant Young

1995: No. 5 QB Kerry Collins

1996: No. 7 WR Terry Glenn

1997: No. 7 WR Ike Hilliard

1999: No. 7 DB Champ Bailey (HOF)

2001: No. 5 RB LaDainian Tomlinson (HOF)

2004: No. 5 DB Sean Taylor

2007: No. 7 RB Adrian Peterson

2010: No. 5 DB Eric Berry

2011: No. 5 DB Patrick Peterson

2014: No. 5 LB Khalil Mack

2014: No. 7 WR Mike Evans

2015: No. 5 OL Brandon Scherff

2016: No. 5 CB Jalen Ramsey

2016: No. 7 DE DeForest Buckner

2018: No. 7 QB Josh Allen

2019: No. 5 LB Devin White

2021: No. 5 WR Ja'Marr Chase