With the offseason about to get into full swing, the Giants.com crew looks at the major storylines for the team heading into 2023:
John Schmeelk: How do the Giants take the next step? Let's have GM Joe Schoen explain where the Giants are in the NFL hierarchy, and whether there is still a gap between them and the Eagles.
Said Schoen: "Yeah, I know Philly more intimately. And, yeah, I would say yes - there's a talent gap there that we need to close, and to me, it's the NFC East. I mean, we were 1-5-1 against the NFC East. If you win the division, the rest takes care of itself. So, that's always going to be a goal of ours: to close that gap and be NFC East champs. That's the goal, and that's what we're going to work towards."
In the NFL this season, there were 16 teams that finished with between seven and nine wins. That's half the league! From season to season, usually half the teams that make the playoffs can change from year to year. Every one of those teams will be trying to improve this off-season, and the Giants will be no different. First, they have to bring back their best players, but someone else will cover that in the contributions below. So, how will the Giants add to the roster?
There are three ways: trade, free agency, and the draft. Trades for upper echelon players are usually pricey when it comes to draft capital, so take that off the table. Free agency can cost a big chunk of salary cap space, but the Giants should have some room to do business in that area. The team must also be prudent and plan for the future with young cornerstones like Dexter Lawrence, Xavier McKinney, and Andrew Thomas coming off their rookie contracts within the next two seasons. A team can't fill every hole in free agency, which leaves the draft.
The Giants have nine draft picks right now, including extra picks in Rounds 3 and 7. They could score a couple of extra compensatory picks late on Day 3, too. With a young team, and the organization still in the early years of a new regime, the draft is the way to build the team. The Giants don't pick until No. 25 overall, so it will be a bit tougher than in past years to find true impact players. Despite that disadvantage, it will still be the main avenue for the team to build out the roster.
It does not appear to be as strong of a wide receiver class as in past years, but good players at that position can often be found well into say Day 2, and potentially into Day 3. It is a strong draft at cornerback, which could make that an interesting target at the end of the first round. Or how about an inside linebacker? They could get the first one off the board. It will be fun to see what positions they target in free agency versus the draft as the off-season moves forward, but it is way too early to know that now.
Dan Salomone: Before they "close that gap" with outside additions, the Giants have decisions to make in-house. Several prominent Giants players are unrestricted free agents, notably Daniel Jones and Saquon Barkley. Like he said in both his introductory press conference and season-ending media session a year later, general manager Joe Schoen knew the "cupboard wasn't bare" and 2022 bore that out. The Giants expressed hey want both players back, but all parties involved know there is a business side to it.
"Everybody is going to step back, take the emotion out of it, evaluate the roster and then, again, we've got to operate under the salary cap," Schoen said. "How are you going to divvy up? How are we going to create the roster? What are the priority positions, and how are we going to move forward?"
This storyline is the first domino that sets the next six months into place.
Re-live the season with the best photos from the Giants' 2022 playoff campaign.
Lance Medow: Clearly, how the Giants approach their own scheduled free agents including Daniel Jones, Saquon Barkley and Julian Love, will top the list but wide receiver is a spot to watch given they can use both the draft and free agency to bolster that spot. Isaiah Hodgins' strong campaign proved to be a pleasant surprise and will more than likely factor into their future plans as he's an exclusive rights free agent. On the flip side, Richie James, Darius Slayton and Sterling Shepard are unrestricted free agents. James led the team in receptions, Slayton receiving yards and Shepard missed the bulk of the year due to a torn ACL he suffered in Week 3.
Although they may consider bringing back some of those internal options, the draft likely will be Joe Schein's main tool to address this position. When you look at recent NFL history, many first-year wideouts immediately contributed and part of that is because wide receiver allows for a relatively smooth transition from college to the pros. Case in point, Garrett Wilson of the Jets, the Saints' Chris Olave and Jahan Dotson of the Commanders are just a few examples from last year's draft class that produced throughout the season. Even Wan'Dale Robinson showed some flashes for the Giants before suffering a season-ending torn ACL in Week 11. He'll be another prospect the Giants can further tap into in 2023 as he gets more and more comfortable within the system.
The Giants will have to use a bulk of their salary cap space to retain some of their key weapons, including the most important position - quarterback. When you take that into consideration and the fact that this year's free agent wide receiver class doesn't showcase many dominant number ones, the most practical game plan is to rely on the draft and continued development of young players at that position.
Matt Citak: The Giants enter the 2023 off-season with several holes to fill on the roster. With cap space and currently nine picks in the upcoming draft (that number could increase based on compensatory picks), Joe Schoen is in a great position to add talent at various spots. Since the wide receiver position has already been discussed by Lance, let's take another key area that Schoen and the front office will have to address this off-season - inside linebacker.
The Giants finished the season with six inside linebackers on the roster, three of which are headed toward free agency. Landon Collins, Jaylon Smith and Jarrad Davis, none of whom began the season with the team, are set to become unrestricted free agents. This leaves Cam Brown, Carter Coughlin and Micah McFadden as the only inside linebackers on the roster. As we know, Brown and Coughlin have developed into perhaps the team's two best special teams players, with each one playing 85 percent of the team's ST snaps this season (398 snaps each). Although each have carved out key roles on the team, neither one has contributed much on defense. Brown played just three defensive snaps this season, while Coughlin totaled six. McFadden saw a lot more playing time on defense as he was on the field for 39 percent of the team's defensive snaps (435). Nonetheless, it's clear the Giants will have to add numerous linebackers over the next few months.
Unlike the wide receiver position, there are plenty of talented linebackers currently set to hit free agency at the start of the new league year in March. The group includes Buccaneers LB Lavonte David, Titans LB David Long and Bills LB Tremaine Edmunds, all of whom land on NFL.com's Top 51 free agents list, in addition to guys such as Bengals LB Germaine Pratt, Colts LB Bobby Okereke and Cowboys LB Leighton Vander Esch. It's safe to say the linebacker position is one that is filled with a lot of players set to hit free agency who could contribute significantly to the Giants' defense in 2023. This, in turn, would allow the Giants to target other positions of need, such as wide receiver or cornerback, in the early parts of the draft.